BulkSignature, and by a wider margin the more you want from the tool. A 100 person company pays $88 a month on BulkSignature and $145 a month on Exclaimer Standard. If you need Exclaimer's Pro features, $175 a month, the gap is about double. Against Exclaimer Starter the difference is just $24 a year, so the choice there is features and vendor, not price.
What you get for the rate matters more than the rate. BulkSignature says one plan includes signatures, banner campaigns and analytics, with Enterprise adding a security and legal review and a dedicated customer success manager. Exclaimer splits those across three tiers. Check on a trial that the exact analytics and CRM connections you need are in the tier you are pricing.
Commitment is similar. Both list a 10 user minimum and a 14 day free trial. BulkSignature says there are no contracts and you can cancel anytime. Exclaimer's published rates assume annual billing. If security paperwork decides it, ask each vendor for its latest SOC 2 report and file the answers with your other SOC 2 compliance evidence.
Whichever you choose, put the renewal date on a calendar. A SaaS management platform that tracks seat counts and renewals keeps a quiet auto renewal from turning into a surprise invoice.